Journal Number Three

I have recieved advice from several sources that it is a really good idea to journal while writing a thesis, and I will. But never being one to do things by halves, rather than stick to one, I am experimenting... with three. I have an academic journal, a personal journal, and now journal number three- this web journal.

Monday, July 26, 2004

Muddling around the edges

I really feel like I am just muddling around the edges of the topic at the moment... doing some literature searching and reading but not feeling like I'm making any progress.  I guess it's still early days.
It doesn't help that there appears to be very little literature on the topic of short term medical missions.  Of course, I knew this was the case before I even started and the lack of literature was one of the justifications I gave in my proposal for doing this research.  At the moment I have a stack of mission "reports" and personal reflections, and a range of literature addressing such diverse but related topics as NGO's in health care, international medicine and nursing and transcultural care. And I'm gradually building a collection of information on health and health care in Honduras. But I'm still working out what I'm going to do with it.... guess if I keep reading it will all fall into place in time.
I felt a little reassured yesterday talking to an acquaintance who has already been through the research process (several times I suspect)... Apparently it is very normal to feel lost at this stage.  I'm actually not particularly worried about the process of writing the thesis, my concern is in my ability to actually collect the data- designing and carrying out the research itself.  But I have been assured that writing is actually the harder part.  I hope that's true...

Sunday, July 18, 2004

Week One

The first "real" week of study is now over... and I feel only slightly less lost than I did a week ago.  I have a desk at the university, a more-or-less complete proposal and a growing pile of books and articles to read.  But while I have a clear sense of long-term direction (write a thesis!) I don't have a very defined path for the immediate future (how am I actually going to achieve this).   So, I'm awaiting my supervisors comments on the proposal, doing some reading and have bought lots of shiney new stationary in an effort to look organised.  I have also booked a "research consultation" at the library for next week (both librarians for the college of Humanities were on leave at the beginning of the semester... not much help to me!).  Truth is, right now I'm really starting to appreciate the term "independent research"!  
 
One book I finally did get through this week was a study by Barbara Parfitt (1998)- Working Across Cultures- A Study of Expatriate Nurses in Developing Countries in Primary Health Care.  While Parfitt's study primarily focuses on nurses working long-term in developing countries it highlighted several issues that I'm interested in.  I was particularly intrigued by Parfitts ideas about power and knowledge- the inherent power of being a white, western health professional in a developing country, and how this can be used both positively and negatively. Parfitt concluded that wherever cross-cultural nursing takes place it is necessary to take account of values which influence practise.  Her argument is that how a western nurse behaves and practises is influenced by his/her beliefs about what constitutes good practise, but that "good care" is defined by the western medical establishment.  I have long been interested in how western-oriented belief and value systems (as a whole, not just in medicine) influence the care given by westerners in non-western environments. It has certainly been my observation to date that many health practitioners are quite unaware of the influence their values have on their practise.. but to what extent is that negative or damaging? Is it relevant at all in the context of short-term medical missions? (feel free to add comments to this post!!)